Efficacy of Traditional Acupuncture Compared to Biofeedback Therapy in Fecal Incontinence: A Randomized Controlled Trial.
Source: PubMed, NCBI / U.S. National Library of Medicine
Fecal incontinence has a devastating impact on quality of life and imposes a substantial socioeconomic burden. Best medical therapy, including biofeedback therapy, improves mild symptoms with minimal impact on moderate to severe symptoms. Surgical management for incontinence carries a degree of morbidity, resulting in low uptake and acceptability. Although acupuncture is common practice in Singapore for numerous medical conditions, its role in fecal incontinence is relatively novel. In our local context, however, acupuncture is accessible, inexpensive, and potentially well accepted as a treatment strategy. To determine the effectiveness of traditional Chinese medicine acupuncture, compared to biofeedback therapy, in the treatment of fecal incontinence. The secondary aim is to investigate the differences in quality of life after treatment. Randomized controlled trial. Prospective, single-institution study. Patients with 2 or more episodes of fecal incontinence per week or St. Mark's incontinence score of 5 or higher were recruited. Patients were randomly assigned into biofeedback therapy, which included 3 sessions over 10 weeks, or 30 sessions of acupuncture over 10 weeks. Incontinence episodes, St. Mark's score, and fecal incontinence quality-of-life scale. Eighty-five patients were randomly assigned to biofeedback therapy (n = 46) or acupuncture (n = 39). Demographics and baseline clinical characteristics were not different ( p > 0.05). Overall median incontinence episodes w
Abstract
Fecal incontinence has a devastating impact on quality of life and imposes a substantial socioeconomic burden. Best medical therapy, including biofeedback therapy, improves mild symptoms with minimal impact on moderate to severe symptoms. Surgical management for incontinence carries a degree of morbidity, resulting in low uptake and acceptability. Although acupuncture is common practice in Singapore for numerous medical conditions, its role in fecal incontinence is relatively novel. In our local context, however, acupuncture is accessible, inexpensive, and potentially well accepted as a treatment strategy. To determine the effectiveness of traditional Chinese medicine acupuncture, compared to biofeedback therapy, in the treatment of fecal incontinence. The secondary aim is to investigate the differences in quality of life after treatment. Randomized controlled trial. Prospective, single-institution study. Patients with 2 or more episodes of fecal incontinence per week or St. Mark's incontinence score of 5 or higher were recruited. Patients were randomly assigned into biofeedback therapy, which included 3 sessions over 10 weeks, or 30 sessions of acupuncture over 10 weeks. Incontinence episodes, St. Mark's score, and fecal incontinence quality-of-life scale. Eighty-five patients were randomly assigned to biofeedback therapy (n = 46) or acupuncture (n = 39). Demographics and baseline clinical characteristics were not different ( p > 0.05). Overall median incontinence episodes were reduced in both, with the acupuncture arm reporting significantly fewer episodes at week 15 ( p < 0.001). Acupuncture also improved quality of life, with improvement in lifestyle, coping, depression, and embarrassment at week 15 ( p < 0.05). Although the St. Mark's score was significantly reduced in both arms at week 15 ( p < 0.001), the acupuncture arm's score was significantly lower ( p = 0.002). Longer follow-up is required. Acupuncture is clinically effective and improves the quality of life in patients with fecal incontinence. See Video Abstract . Clinicaltrials.gov : NCT04276350. ANTECEDENTES:La incontinencia fecal tiene un impacto devastador en la calidad de vida e impone una carga socioeconómica sustancial. La mejor terapia médica, incluida la terapia de biorretroalimentación, mejora los síntomas leves, con un impacto mínimo sobre los síntomas moderados a graves. El tratamiento quirúrgico de la incontinencia conlleva un grado de morbilidad que resulta en una baja aceptación y aceptabilidad. Si bien la acupuntura es una práctica común en Singapur para numerosas afecciones médicas, su papel en la incontinencia fecal es relativamente novedoso. Sin embargo, en nuestro contexto local, la acupuntura es accesible, económica y potencialmente bien aceptada como estrategia de tratamiento.OBJETIVO:Determinar la efectividad de la acupuntura de la Medicina Tradicional China, en comparación con la terapia de biorretroalimentación en el tratamiento de la incontinencia fecal. El objetivo secundario es investigar las diferencias en la calidad de vida después del tratamiento.DISEÑO:Ensayo controlado aleatorio.AJUSTE:Estudio prospectivo de una sola institución.PACIENTES:Se reclutaron pacientes con >2 episodios de incontinencia fecal/semana o una puntuación de incontinencia de St. Mark's >5. Los pacientes fueron asignados aleatoriamente a una terapia de biorretroalimentación que incluyó 3 sesiones durante 10 semanas o 30 sesiones de acupuntura durante 10 semanas.PRINCIPALES MEDIDAS DE RESULTADO:Episodios de incontinencia, puntuación de St. Mark's y escala de calidad de vida de incontinencia fecal.RESULTADOS:Ochenta y cinco pacientes fueron asignados aleatoriamente a terapia de biorretroalimentación (n = 46) o acupuntura (n = 39). Las características demográficas y clínicas iniciales no fueron diferentes ( p > 0,05). La mediana general de episodios de incontinencia se redujo en ambos, y el grupo de acupuntura informó significativamente menos en la semana 15 ( p <0,001). La acupuntura también mejoró la calidad de vida, con mejoras en el estilo de vida, el afrontamiento, la depresión y la vergüenza en la semana 15 ( p <0,05). Mientras que la puntuación de St Mark se redujo significativamente en ambos brazos en la semana 15 ( p < 0,001), la puntuación del brazo de acupuntura fue significativamente menor (p = 0,002).LIMITACIONES:Se requiere un seguimiento más prolongado.CONCLUSIONES:La acupuntura es clínicamente efectiva y mejora la calidad de vida en pacientes con incontinencia fecal. (Traducción-Dr Yolanda Colorado ).